The LearnerÕs Companion:
A Student Reference Guide to Foundation Skills at
the
School
of Environmental Studies
2003-2004
GUIDELINES FOR WORKING IN A GROUPÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 2
GUIDELINES FOR SOCRATIC SEMINARÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 3
GUIDELINES FOR FISHBOWL DISCUSSIONSÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 5
GUIDELINES FOR LEARNING CIRCLESÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 6
STEPS IN CRITICAL READINGÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 7
ACTIVE READING GUIDELINESÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 7
JOURNALING AT SESÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ8
FIELD WRITINGÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 9
DOCUMENT CONVENTIONS AT SESÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ10
GUIDELINES FOR THE WRITING PROCESSÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ11
CHECKLIST FOR EFFECTIVE WRITINGÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 12
HELP WITH EDITINGÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ12
TIPS FOR REVISION: THE ACADEMIC ESSAYÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ13
GUIDELINES FOR COMPUTER USE AT SESÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ14
GUIDELINES FOR DATA COLLECTIONÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ14
GUIDELINES FOR THE RESEARCH PROCESSÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 15
ACADEMIC INTEGRITY & RESPONSIBILITYÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 16
DOCUMENTATION GUIDE (MLA STYLE)ÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 17
DOCUMENTATION GUIDE (APA STYLE)ÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 19
CHECKLIST FOR EFFECTIVE SPEAKINGÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 20
GUIDELINES FOR USING THE MINNESOTA ZOOÉÉÉÉÉÉÉ 21
A MODEL FOR A WRITING & THINKING PROCESS FOR SESÉÉ.22

Good
Working GroupsÉ Ineffective
Working Groups...
Are cooperative Are
competitive
Make constructive use of conflict Let conflict divide the group
Distribute power among many Limit power to a few
Make optimum use of all resources Make limited use of resources
Encourage freedom of expression Inhibit expression of ideas
Follow an orderly problem-solving sequence Reflect disorderly, nonlogical thinking
Give all participants the chance to satisfy their Give only a few the chance to satisfy
personal needs their personal needs
Provide some opportunity for training in Disregard the need for training
leadership skills in leadership skills
Move toward removing feeling of dependency Increase the dependency on a single
on one leader leader
Reflect a willingness of all to accept Develop a disregard for individual
responsibility for accomplishing group tasks responsibility toward the groupÕs goals
Enable the group to make decisions affecting its Leave all decisions affecting the groupÕs
progress process to a few
Provide maximum opportunity for the Increase feelings of threat and defense
development of feelings of security
Reflect active emotional and intellectual Reflect disinterest and a noncommittal
involvement in the subject attitude toward the subject
1. Have clear, consistent goals
2. Be open, fair, and willing to listen
3. Be decisive (and decide as a group how you will make decisions)
4. Support all other team members
5. Take responsibility for team actions
6. Give credit to team members
7. Be sensitive to the needs of team members
8. Respect the opinions of others
9. Empower team members to act
(from
Why Teams DonÕt Work, Harvey Robbins and Michael Finley,
1995)
GUIDELINES FOR SOCRATIC SEMINAR
ÒI would contend at all
costs both in word and deed as far as I could that we will be better humans,
braver and less idle, if we believe that one must search for the things one
does not know, rather than if we believe that it is not possible to find out
what we do not know and that we must not look for it.Ó (Socrates, in PlatoÕs Meno)
Almost
2,500 years ago, Socrates walked his students through the city streets of
ancient Greece and encouraged them to ask questions about everything they
saw. The students discussed possible answers to questions and constructed
their own understanding of the truth. SocratesÕ philosophy of teaching
was quite simple: as human beings, we possess an amazing amount of knowledge
and understanding; however, we often fail to realize how much we already
know. He believed that
through the process of dialogue, where all parties to the conversation were
forced to clarify their ideas, the final outcome of the conversation would be a
clear statement of meaning.
Socrates would feign ignorance about a subject and try to draw out from
the other person his fullest possible knowledge about it. If the human mind was incapable of
knowing something, Socrates wanted to demonstrate that, too. One of his core beliefs was, ÒThe
unexamined life is not worth living.Ó (from
http://www.secondaryenglish.com/dream_is_the_truth.htm)
What is a Socratic
Seminar?
A specialized form of DISCUSSION, in which a group attempts to
Create a DIALECTIC (the art or
practice of examining opinions or ideas logically, often by the
method of question and answer, so as to determine their validity)
In regards to a specific TEXT (thought-provoking,
multi-leveled primary texts are best)
To collectively seek deeper UNDERSTANDING of complex ideas
Through rigorously thoughtful DIALOGUE
Dialogue is characterized by:
á
Suspending judgment
á
Examining our own work
without defensiveness
á
Exposing our reasoning
and looking for limits to it
á
Communicating our
underlying assumptions
á
Exploring viewpoints
more broadly and deeply
á
Being open to
disconfirming data
á
Approaching someone who
sees a problem differently not as an adversary, but as a colleague in common
pursuit of a better solution
á
Developing the voice of
each participant
|
Teacher leads
the discussion |
Teacher
facilitates the discussion |
|
Teacher is
separate from students |
Students and
teacher are in a circle |
|
97% teacher
talk |
97% student
talk |
|
Average
student response time is 8-12 seconds |
Average
student response time is 2-3 seconds |
|
Teacher
affirmation of correctness is expected |
Affirming
feedback from teacher is taboo |
|
ÒRightnessÓ
is paramount |
Thinking,
supported with evidence, is paramount |
|
Students
listen to the teacher, who has the answer |
Students
listen primarily to peers |
|
Teacher has
ownership for the ÒflowÓ |
Students have
ownership for the ÒflowÓ |
|
This table
adapted from http://cte.jhu.edu/techacademy/web/2000/kajder/studentresp.html |
|
|
Collaborative:
multiple sides work toward shared understanding. |
Oppositional:
two opposing sides try to prove each other wrong. |
|
One listens
to understand, to make meaning, and to find common ground. |
One listens
to find flaws, to spot differences, and to counter arguments. |
|
Enlarges and
possibly changes a participant's point of view. |
Defends
assumptions as truth. |
|
Creates an
open-minded attitude: an openness to being wrong and an openness to change. |
Creates a
close-minded attitude, a determination to be right. |
|
One submits
one's best thinking, expecting that other people's reflections will help
improve it rather than threaten it. |
One submits
one's best thinking and defends it against challenge to show that it is
right. |
|
Calls for
temporarily suspending one's beliefs. |
Calls for
investing wholeheartedly in one's beliefs. |
|
One searches
for strengths in all positions. |
One searches
for weaknesses in the other position. |
|
Respects all
the other participants and seeks not to alienate or offend. |
Rebuts
contrary positions and may belittle or deprecate other participants. |
|
Assumes that
many people have pieces of answers and that cooperation can lead to a greater
understanding. |
Assumes a
single right answer that somebody already has. |
|
Remains
open-ended. |
Demands a
conclusion. |
|
This table
adapted from http://www.mcps.k12.md.us/schools/wjhs/depts/socialst/ams/Skills/SocraticSeminar/SocraticSeminarIntro.html |
|
What is my Role as a
Participant in a Socratic Seminar?
Prepare Individually
á Read the text carefully, following the steps to critical reading
á Try to understand the basic ideas, concepts and vocabulary of the text
á Think of questions that the text raises for you
Engage in Shared Inquiry
á Keep the discussion focused on the text.
á Ask thoughtful questions that raise issues, lead to further questions, and require more than a Òyes or noÓ answer (remember SocratesÕ idea of the dialectic).
á
Support your views with evidence from the text.
á Seek to understand everyoneÕs views and questions. Ask for clarification,;restate ideas.
á Use Òintellectual etiquetteÓ---be patient and polite as if the conversation were happening with guests at your dinner table.
á Observe the group carefully---be aware of body language as well as what is said.
á Be skeptical of unsupported statements; but never criticize the person.
á Follow the conversation closely; keep adding to it without repeating ground thatÕs already been covered. Taking notes will help your trace the discussion.
á Include everyone in the group; encourage everyone to participate.
á Be prepared to change your mind as a result of the conversation; be open to new views.
á Take risks; there are no wrong answers.
á Have fun!
GUIDELINES FOR FISHBOWL DISCUSSIONS
What is a ÒfishbowlÓ discussion?
A student-led, shared inquiry into a text or topic, like a
Socratic Seminar. Like a Socratic
Seminar, the teacherÕs role is to get the conversation started and to step in
only when the discussants are stuck.
Unlike a Socratic Seminar, students discussing in a ÒfishbowlÓ are
observed by other students, whose role is to examine the process of the
discussion and provide feedback.
Why do we have ÒfishbowlÓ discussions?
HereÕs how a ÒfishbowlÓ works:
Half the group will sit in a circle; they will be the discussants (ÒfishÓ in a ÒfishbowlÓ). The other half will sit in a circle around the discussants; they will be the observers (ÒfisherpersonsÓ studying the ÒfishÓ).
Guidelines for the ÒFisherpersonsÓ:
Your task is to chart and evaluate the process of the discussion as well as its contents, and then after the discussion, to share what you have observed with the Òfish,
á Listen and observe carefully.
á Take detailed notes so that you can accurately summarize the process.
á Offer positive feedback and constructive criticism---your goal is to help the ÒfishÓ improve their discussion skills.
Guidelines for the ÒFishÓ:
Your task is to conduct an in-depth, interesting discussion on the designated topic(s). Follow the guidelines below:
á You should only be a ÒfishÓ if you have prepared for the discussion (you should have notes, annotations, journal entries or other assigned work as evidence of preparation).
á Take detailed notes to trace lines of thinking, to help yourself avoid making repetitive or Òdead-endÕ comments, and to help yourself remember the discussion later.
á Offer specific examples and evidence from your reading to support your contributions.
á Encourage those who are monopolizing to share, and those who are quiet to speak up.
á Ask questions to allow the discussion to expand.
á Restate ideas and ask clarifying questions.
á Keep the discussion moving.
á Maintain an open mind.
á Disagree with a personÕs ideas, but avoid criticizing the person.
á Listen carefully.
á Communicate clearly.
á Have fun.
GUIDELINES FOR LEARNING CIRCLES
What is a Learning Circle?
Learning Circles are rooted in the practice of democratic education. As teachers, we find that we donÕt get to hear from our students enough. We spend time talking and explaining what we think you need to hear to better understand the curriculum. This is why a learning circle is exceptionally refreshing. It guarantees every single person a chance to voice their thoughts on the same subject. In light of democratic education, every person has reserved air space to voice their opinion or tell their story without it getting interrupted or vacuumed up by the surrounding voices.
Learning Circles center around a predetermined prompt shared by a facilitator. Prompts are most effective and least controversial when people are asked to tell some sort of story about their life experience. Brain research also affirms that most learning is connected to our emotional memory in some way and thus, connections between our personal lives and new experiences can provide powerful learning experiences.
What are my responsibilities as a facilitator?
á The biggest responsibility of the facilitator is to create a space for everyone to be heard. Facilitators introduce the prompt, give people a chance to write or think about their response, and then begin by going clockwise around the circle encouraging people, one by one, to share their thoughts.
á The facilitator carefully listens to the comments shared by EACH group member.
á By carefully hearing what people are saying, the facilitator may choose to offer a follow-up question that addresses some further thoughts on the same or related topic.
á Facilitators must be willing to preserve the topic at hand. In other words, if a group member is so compelled to speak up and affirm or disagree with what the speaker is saying, then the facilitator must be willing to preserve the original speakerÕs air space and ask the interrupter to table the matter for later. The facilitator should make a conscientious effort and be sure to come back to this tabled matter after the first Ògo-roundÓ of the circle.
á WhatÕs the point of going around the circle in order? By going around the circle in order, speakers know when they will speakÑit is as simple as that; by going in order people can anticipate when they will be sharing with the group. If speakers are not ready to talk yet, thatÕs fine, the facilitator will come back to them.
á WhatÕs the point of not letting other topics come up? Actually, other topics do come up in an organic fashion. Most speakers that share toward the end of the group are likely to have evolved their thought based on what they have heard already. This is fineÑthis is the way ideas shape ideas.
á Circle go-rounds: Most facilitators will have at least two circle go-rounds followed by an informal discussion. If facilitators read their group well, they will be able to come up with another prompt following the first one that pushes the participants to further their insight and thinking process.
á Whenever actions can connect to what has been discussed, the learner may feel more in control of a situation. Facilitators should listen carefully to participants and or the reading and consider when a prompt might incorporate actions one can take. This is where the cycle of transformation/democratic learning gains momentum.
Knowledge 1. Skim
the text
¥
identify author, context, the general idea
¥
ask yourself what you will look for as you read
Comprehension 2. Decipher
the content
¥
identify thesis
¥
identify main ideas, evidence & reasoning
¥
search for "5 W's & an H" (who?, what?, when?, where?, why?,
how?)
Analysis 3. Examine
text piece by piece (take it apart)
¥
what is the writer saying?
¥
why is s/he saying it? what's the purpose?
¥
why is s/he saying it in this way? whatÕs the style?
¥
what is the effect?
Evaluation 4. Criticize
the text
¥
do you agree or disagree?
¥
how effectively does the writer convey the message
Synthesis 5. Interpret the text (put it back together)
¥
explain the ideas in context
¥
relate the ideas to other ideas, other texts, the real world
¥
relate the text to yourself & your own life
ÒAs a reader, you are not a passive receptacle into which
meaning is poured. Nor are you a
decoder, deciphering the black marks on a page to discover the textÕs
message. A better analogy for
reading is translating: As you
read, you transfer into your own words what you understand the page to meanÓ (Rise Axelrod, Reading Critically, Writing Well)
At SES, we expect students to be active readers; we recommend a two-step procedure:
Active readers interact with the text by highlighting, underlining and commenting as they read. On photocopied readings or in your own copies of books, you can annotate right on the page. On SES texts, you can annotate by using post-it notes, flags, tabs, etc. and taking notes in your notebook.
There is no right or wrong way to annotate----find what works for you. Some ideas on what to mark and how to comment:
á
Mark or note any passage
that interests, excites or confuses you
á
Bracket or note
important passages
á
Underline, highlight or note key words, terms,
concepts
á
Outline the main ideas
in the margin or in your notebook
á
Circle or note words you
need to define
á
Write questions to ask a
teacher, your friends, or in a discussion
á
Notice patterns and
evolving themes
á
Record enthusiasms (Yes!
I agree!) and resistances (Huh? Hmmm. No!)
á
Mark statements that
summarize main ideas, concepts, themes
á
Record brief summaries
of ideas
Active readers are continually exploring their understanding
of and response to the text. The
act of composing sentences or engaging in conversation about a text will lead
you to clarify and extend your ideas and to discover new insights about what
you have read. You should jot your thoughts as and after you read in your
notebook or journal and be prepared to share your ideas in discussion.
What are the
Characteristics of Good Journaling?
1. Journaling can be used as a:
¥ Prewriting tool---generating ideas for
an essay
¥ Pre-reading tool---preparation for critical reading
¥ Comprehension tool---review of reading,
lectures, etc. to check your understanding
¥ Observation tool---sharpening your
observational skills
¥ Reflection tool---sharpening your
reflective thinking skills
¥ Analytical tool---practicing your
analytical or problem-solving skills
¥ Evaluative tool---weighing and evaluating ideas or knowledge
¥ Therapeutic tool---working through your
feelings
¥ Questioning tool---generating (possibly
answering) questions about what you hear, see,
read, etc.
2. Journaling is FREEWRITING---the idea is to write freely, without worrying about
correct spelling & grammar, to try out ideas without worrying about their
logic or completeness.
3. Journaling should be THOUGHTFUL WRITING. Push
yourself to write as much as you can in the allotted time, although quality
of thought (note: not
necessarily quality of "correct writing") is more important than
quantity of words.
4. Journaling can be CREATIVE. Feel
free to sketch, "paint with words," try out new ideas.
5. Journaling must be PERSONAL WRITING. The
person you should really be trying to impress in your journal is yourself. Your journal is your "letter"
to yourself, you are "dumping" your brain onto paper. Be honest and speak in your own
"voice."
Journal Expectations at SES
Think of your journal as an
ÒeverythingÓ book: a place to
collect data, to take notes, to respond to readings, to reflect upon your
experiences at SES, to try out ideas, to prepare for discussions, to record
your thoughts and questions.
Lecture notes, field notes, personal reflections, sketches, maps,
annotations of readings---in other words, everything except handouts or essays should be included in your
journal. Your journal will
be a chronological record of your experience at SES, a way for you to trace
your learning throughout the year...something to keep and treasure.
Basic Journal Requirements:
á Your journal should be a minimum of 8Ó by 10Ówith a hard cover to withstand the weather (a typical Òcomposition bookÓ works well).
á Clearly label & date each entry (you may have several entries each day).
á Label field notes with additional information including: date, time, location, and weather conditions.
á Number the pages sequentially.
á Record entries chronologically...if you are absent, please carefully note this on pages which may be out of order.
á Keep your journal current (filling in the blanks two weeks later will be of little value to your learning).
á Write legibly (remember that it will be evaluated by your teachers).
á Buy a ziplock bag to keep your journal waterproof.
á Keep a glue stick or tape handy for pasting in some items (like this!).
á Beautify your journal with art and color.
You will be completing field observations and writing as
part of our exploration of the environment around SES, and you will be doing
three types of writing in and about the field studies. You will be sharpening your
observation skills and descriptive writing skills while learning more about the
habitats and organisms around us.
We will expect you to follow the formats that follow whenever we go out
to explore. You should use a field journal,
which should be hard-covered to withstand the outdoors.
Date each entry and mark it with a descriptive title.
Field Notes
In this type of writing, your goal is to record specific data as you complete careful observations in the field. Details cannot be accurately retained unless you write them down at the time of observation, which is why you should take careful, thorough notes as you study in the field. Think of your field notes as a "scrapbook" in which you collect verbal mementos of your study. Include labeled sketches, drawings, and maps. If you are not in a park or wildlife refuge, you may collect leaves or other organic materials to include in your "scrapbook."
For each entry of field notes, you should record the:
á date
á time
á weather
Include atmospheric conditions, temperature, wind, humidity, cloud cover, etc.
á location and/or route traveled:
Pinpoint the precise location so that you or someone else can find it again (maybe a map?).
á habitat:
Include topography, soil characteristics, geologic features, bodies of water, etc.
á vegetation:
Describe the plant community (usually named for the two dominant plant species) on the site. Describe the extent of plant cover, height, trunk diameter (for trees), and phenology of the development of the plants.
á species observed (flora & fauna):
List the species in a column or in a narrative format. Separate plant, mammal and bird lists. Note bird songs you hear. Whenever possible, you should record numbers with your list (how many male cardinals and how many female cardinals?) and mark if you are estimating rather than doing an exact count.
á general
commentary as you observe
Field Reflections
Field reflections are your commentary on the specific
details you have recorded in your field notebook. You may do this kind of writing out in the field, or you may
write after you have completed your field work; no later than the evening of the day you have been in the
field. Think of your journal as a
"journey," in which you mentally relive the trip you took in the field,
recording the highlights and disappointments of travel. Think of field journaling as a memoir
(NOT a diary) of your time in the field.
When we say Òyour essay
should be in SES Format,Ó we generally are referring to the following
guidelines, which are a modification of the guidelines of the Modern Language
Association (MLA). We have chosen
to make these modifications to enhance resource conservation in our work. Other
schools and publishers may require a different citation format. Always find out what format is
required for your audience, and follow that format.
Unless specified otherwise by your teacher, follow these conventions in preparing word-processed assignments at SES:
á Font:
Times
Regular
style
12
point
Black
á Paragraph:
Alignment
left (left justified)
Indentation .5Ó
Double Spaced
á
Document:
1Ó margins all
around
á Case: Sentence case (Each sentence begins with a capital letter; donÕt use all capitals)
á
Page numbers: after
the first page, use a right justified header with the page number; you may
choose to incorporate a shortened title or your name with the number
á
Title Page: not
required, to save paper
á First Page:
Place
your name and date in the upper right corner,
Center
a title to your paper using Title Case (capitalize all words except a, an,
the or prepositions); donÕt underline
it or put it in quotation marks
Double
or triple space after the title and begin the first paragraph
á Punctuation Spacing:
Type
one space after a comma or semicolon.
Type
two spaces after a period or colon.
á Quotation Spacing:
If
the quotation is 4 lines or fewer, just incorporate it into your
paragraph, using quotation marks.
If
the quotation is more than 4 lines, single space and indent the quote as
a block. Do not use quotation
marks.
á Parenthetical Citations:
Whenever you
paraphrase or quote a source, use a parenthetical citation giving the authorÕs
last name and the page number.
Watch the punctuation carefully in the following example:
ÒSES is a great placeÓ (Bodette 46).
(notice: no punctuation in
the quotation, no p. or pp. in the citation, period after the parentheses)
á Works Cited:
Whenever sources are
cited, include a Works Cited section at the end of the paper. To save paper, you are not required to
put the Works Cited on a separate page.
Just double or triple space after your last sentence, center the title
Works Cited (not in italics, capital letters, or underlined) double space, and
list your sources using the format outlined later in this packet.
á
Printing Back to Back: Whenever possible, print on both sides of the paper
á
Naming Organisms: Capitalize
the common names of organisms: Quaking Aspen, Red Oak
Italicize the scientific name, capitalizing the genus
but not the species:
Populus
tremuloides, Quercus rubra
If
you are unsure of the species, just list the genus and the abbreviation of
Òunknown speciesÓ:
Populus sp., Quercus sp
Prewriting
q Select a topic that interests you.
q Establish a purpose and personal goals.
q Narrow the topic until it can be thoroughly developed in a specified length according to your teacherÕs instructions.
q Identify an audience and determine word choice, tone and details to be included.
q Gather and develop information, including quotes that support your ideas.
q Evaluate the details and delete details that stray from your writing purpose.
q Keeping your audience and purpose in mind, begin to write freely.
q Explore various ways to organize your material without excessive focus on grammar and punctuation.
q Decide on a logical, effective organizational format. Know if the main ideas are best related in terms of time, space, importance, or a combination of these.
Read what you have written; then answer the following questions:
q Do the details you present relate directly to your main topic/focus?
q Is your material organized effectively and logically and are the relationships between the main ideas clear?
q Are there unnecessary or unrelated ideas?
q Does each paragraph have a topic sentence and focus clearly on a single main idea?
q Does the writing flow smoothly with the use of transitions?
q Is there a clear and logical introduction, body and conclusion?
q Is there variety in type and structure of your sentences?
q Is there vivid and precise word choice to establish voice and tone?
q Is your language and content appropriate for your audience?
q Have you accomplished your goal?
A Paragraph = QUs + As + Ds
|
QU (Questions) |
A (Answers) |
D (Details) |
|
What is the topic sentence? |
|
|
|
First support? |
|
|
|
Second support? |
|
|
|
Third Support? |
|
|
|
What is the conclusion? |
|
|
Ideas and Content
q Ideas are appropriate, well developed, supported with meaningful information
q
Relationships between ideas and examples are clear and
powerful
Organization
q Main idea clearly expressed, supporting information presented in a logical, effective sequence
q Transitions are smooth
q Clear introduction and conclusion are present
q Quotes are effectively integrated into the writing
Voice
q Essay has the ring of conviction
q Reader feels strong sense of interaction with writer
q
Expression is individualistic and engaging
Word Choice (Diction)
q Word choice is specific and accurate
q Variety is used; repetition is avoided
q Language is vivid or energetic in appropriate measure
q Language is creatively used
Sentence Fluency (Syntax)
q Sentence structure reflects logic and sense, helping to show how ideas relate
q Sentences flow naturally and are varied in structure
Conventions
q Paragraphs create sound structure
q Grammar and usage are correct
q Punctuation is smooth, guides reader
q Spelling is correct
q Correct use of quotations and documentation style
WriterÕs Inc. and Write for College offer many suggestions.
Some helpful Internet sources with advice for writing and editing your papers:
á On-line Writing Lab at Purdue University: http://owl.english.purdue.edu (has many links to other on-line writing labs)
á Guide to Grammar & Writing: http://webster.commnet.edu/HP/pages/darling/grammar.htm
á Website for Writers Inc., Write for College, and other student writing helpers: http://thewritesource.com
Many of the essays you write at SES will be formal, academic essays which require the defense of a thesis. In the creation of such essays, revision is an important step. Think of revision as restructuring your writing, not just cleaning up errors. As you think about how to shape your draft into an effective essay, use these tips for revision.
1. In an academic essay, make sure you have a solid, clear thesis. It should be:
á a confident statement (not "I think", "I believe.Ó or ÒI feelÓ)
á a position / argument / opinion / assertion to be proven (not a summary or a fact)
á arguable/debatable and supportable
á a focus for your paper (but not a preview, like "In this paper I'm going to. . ."or "There are three parts to . . .")
á narrow enough to manage in your essay
á presented in one clear statement (not a question)
2. Next make sure that each supporting paragraph has a clear topic sentence that links back to the thesis. Each paragraph is a "mini argument" that supports the main argument presented in the thesis. Remember that an argument has a premise (your topic sentence), support, and a conclusion (your concluding sentence). All of those pieces have to link together to make each paragraph's argument logical, and each paragraph has to link logically to the thesis. This linking is called unity. If there are sentences that don't link logically or are irrelevant, remove them. If links are missing, add them.
3. The supporting evidence in each paragraph must be sufficient to prove the topic sentence, and ultimately your thesis. Make sure that your supporting evidence includes examples, quotations (properly cited), facts, etc. When you use quotes, be sure to integrate them into the paragraph by using transitions and introductory phrases that tie the quotes to your point. Avoid just dropping in quotes, and make sure that they fit your point.
4. To support your topic sentence, and thesis, it is not enough to toss in evidence. You must also use reasoning, which includes drawing inferences from the evidence and explaining how the evidence supports your point. Make sure that you have used good reasoning in each paragraph.
5. When another person reads your paper, the ideas should show coherence. That means all of the ideas connect, are consistent, and flow together smoothly with good transitions.
6. A final area for restructuring your paper is to examine the style of your writing. Each sentence should be a complete idea that makes sense. You should use varied sentence structures and clear, effective wording. You should avoid vague words and generalizations.
After you have examined your draft and considered the above tips, carefully revise your draft, reshaping it to be more effective. Once you have revised your draft, the next step will be editing, which is the final scan for mechanical errors in grammar, usage, spelling, punctuation, citation, margins, etc.
Philosophy of
Computing
DonÕt Panic!
Computing is a community activity.
Patience is crucial.
ÒFreedom is
responsibility realizedÓ (Schiller)
We are all responsible for all of the computers at SES:
á We have free access to computers throughout the building.
á We are respectful of our computers and the computing environment.
á We use computers for academic purposes only (no games, personal email, chat rooms, etc.)
á We leave our computer as we found it. We donÕt change desktop patterns, control panels, etc.
á We are environmentally responsible and save paper and toner as much as possible (use print preview, print only when necessary, print on both sides of the paper whenever possible, reuse and recycle paper).
á We avoid potential problems by saving frequently and remembering our passwords.
á We prepare the computer for the next user (quit the application and drag the log out of the server when you leave the computer).
Data:
Defined as information measured directly
I. Are the data collected appropriate to the task or objective?
- identify the task and objectives
- identify the data needed to complete the task or objective
II. What is needed in order to collect data?
- select equipment (calibrate when necessary)
- select sample size
* Double check with the objective
III. How are the data going to be collected?
- In your notebook or logbook, describe the data collection process.
(description should be detailed enough so others can duplicate the process)
- set up a data table with appropriate labels and units
- collect data and record results
(determine the appropriate level of accuracy)
* Double check with the objective
IV. What analysis is needed to accomplish the task or objective?
- apply appropriate calculations
(show formulas used and calculations with units on all numbers)
- use charts and graphs when appropriate
* Double check with the objective
V. How are the data to be interpreted?
- relate the analyzed data to the identified task or objective
* Double check with the objective
ÒResearch is to see
what everybody else has seen, and to think what nobody else has thought.Ó Albert Szent-Gyorgyi
10 Steps to Research
1. Select an interesting subject that is practical for the time and resources available.
2. Brainstorm what you already know about the subject.
3. Develop some questions about your subject that you would like to answer.
4. Gather some general information about your subject, trying to answer some of your questions:
á talk to people who might have some knowledge about your subject
á do a word search on keywords for your topic
á search electronic guides such as Infotrac (the IMC at SES has an extensive list of online resources)
á do some exploratory reading in reference books, magazines, newspapers, etc.
á view some videos, DVDs, CD-ROMs, etc.
á surf the Internet
5. Prepare a preliminary bibliography (see WriterÕs Inc. or Write for College for format)
6. Limit your subject; focus on what aspect interests you most. Develop a thesis that will give you focus as you continue your research.
7. Gather specific information about your thesis. Take copious notes or photocopy pertinent material as you continue to search:
á primary sources (informed people who you interview, results of your own surveys/questionnaires, your own direct observations, or an authorÕs original work)
á secondary sources (the published words of informed people or their observations, or the results of surveys done by others, found in print or electronic sources)
á tertiary sources (the published or unpublished words of people who are quoting or interpreting the informed peopleÕs words)
A primary source is always
considered to have more validity than a secondary or tertiary source.
EXAMPLE:
á Primary: You interview Albert Einstein, or read an article by him, in which he says that E=mc2.
á Secondary: You read a book written by Dan Bodette, in which he writes about EinsteinÕs theory that E=mc2.
á Tertiary: You read the Enquirer, which tells you about Dan BodetteÕs book that discusses BodetteÕs interpretation of EinsteinÕs theory that E=mc2, (and that he got this theory from aliens)
8. As you search the various sources, you should:
á summarize (reduce what you have read to a few important points, using your own words)
á paraphrase (restate what you have read, using your own words and putting quotation marks around any key words or phrases you borrow from the original source)
á use a direct quotation (record the sourceÕs exact words in quotation marks)
It is extremely important that you carefully credit your sources for their words and ideas. Ethical researchers respect their sources by appropriately citing their work. As you write your paper, you will have to use a parenthetical citation for any information you have summarized or paraphrased as well as directly quoted.
9. Periodically stop to re-examine your thesis. Refocus your search; create some more questions; refine your thesis.
10. Conduct more research based on your refined thesis. Keep adding to your bibliography.
Warning: you may need to repeat steps seven through ten several times before you feel you have found enough information and refined your thesis to the point where you can begin drafting your preliminary paper.
ÒResearch
will not become your own when you simply piece together the ideas of others and
call it a research paperÓ (Patrick Sebranek et al.).
Academic integrity to essential to excellence in education, and at SES we accept the responsibility of maintaining an academic culture that respects honesty. In completing your coursework at SES, we expect you will not participate, either directly or indirectly, in cheating or plagiarism, and you will actively discourage cheating or plagiarism by others.
At its worst, plagiarism is deliberate dishonesty. You are probably aware of what constitutes academic cheating, a personÕs attempt to receive credit for work that they did not do. Typical examples include: copying a friendÕs work and presenting it as your own (or allowing another student to copy your work), revealing or receiving the content of a test, having another person write a paper for you, using technology inappropriately to complete assignments, using crib notes or cheat sheets,, making up quotes for your paper, and so on. Such deliberate cheating is a serious offense in an academic community.
Sometimes plagiarism may be the result of ignorance or insecurity. By definition, plagiarism is the use of passages, materials, words or ideas that come from someone else without properly identifying the source. Even the sequence of ideas or the arrangement of material is unique to a source, and technically cannot be transferred into your own writing without giving credit to the source. When conducting research and writing papers, you have the responsibility for avoiding plagiarism.
In word-for-word plagiarism, a researcher repeats the exact words of a source without giving the necessary credit. Paraphrase plagiarism occurs when a researcher says basically the same thing as an original source with just a few words changed. In spot plagiarism, a researcher uses only a sourceÕs key words or phrases as his or her own without giving credit. Remember, you must document your source whenever you use a direct quotation, a paraphrase, or a summary of that source.
Academic integrity requires you to give credit for the ideas you use, unless the ideas are widely accepted as Òcommon knowledge.Ó Information is considered common knowledge if most people already know it, or if it can be found in nearly any basic reference book on the subject. (The fact that there are 365 days in the year is common knowledge; the fact that it rained 210 days in Seattle during 1990 is not.)
Because we have a collaborative community environment at
SES, we must be careful to distinguish what is acceptable in collaborative work
and what violates the principles of ethical scholarhip. When in doubt, ask a teacher.
Most academic disciplines have their own manuals of style
for documentation of sources used in research and writing. For most papers at SES, you will
follow the MLA Style, guidelines for
documentation published by the Modern Language Association (MLA). This documentation style is used
in most humanities courses in college (literature, history, philosophy,
etc.) Other schools and publishers
may require a different citation format.
Always find out what format is required for your audience, or by your
instructor, and follow that format.
MLA format is discussed
in detail with examples in WriterÕs Inc. #259-284, or Write for College # 300-371. A continually updated source for the most current
guidelines for MLA Style can be found on the MLA website. Go to http://www.mla.org/style
Two unique features of the MLA format include the use of parenthetical
citations (rather than footnotes) and a Works
Cited section (rather than a Bibliography
or list of References).
Using Quotations Responsibly
A paper that is Òquotation heavyÓ usually means a writer has not done much independent thinking. When you do quote material directly, be sure that the capitalization, punctuation, and spelling are the same as that in the original work. Any changes you make should be clearly marked for your readers.
Short Quotations
If a quotation is four typed lines or fewer, work it into the body of your paper and put quotation marks around it.
Long Quotations
Quotations of more than four typed lines should be set off from the rest of the writing by indenting each line 10 spaces and single-spacing the material. Do not use quotation marks.
Generally, a colon is used to introduce quotations set off from the text.
Partial Quotations
If you want to leave out part of the quotation, use an ellipsis to signify the omission. An
ellipsis (. . .) is three periods with a space before and after each one, without the parentheses.
Note - anything you take out of a quotation should not change the authorÕs original meaning.
Adding to Quotations
Use brackets [like this] to signify any material you add within a quotation to help clarify its meaning.
Parenthetical Citations
When you give credit to your sources within the paper, follow these guidelines:
á Insert the appropriate information (usually authorÕs last name and page number) in parentheses after the words or ideas borrowed from another source.
á Place your parentheses where a pause would naturally occur (usually at the end of a sentence).
á
Make sure all the sources you cite in your paper are
also listed in the Works Cited section.
á Introduce the beginning of borrowed material to distinguish it from your own writing. Typically this is done with a brief introduction of the author and some reference to his/her credentials. For example:
Lynette and Thomas Long, two of the foremost
recognized experts on the trend of latchkey children, define latchkey as, Ò. .
. children who are regularly left during some period of the day to supervise
themselves . . . or for whom care arrangements are so loosely made they are
virtually ineffectiveÓ (Long 17).
Works Cited
At the end of your paper, you should include a section in which you provide detailed information about the sources you have cited in your paper (NOT all the sources you consulted in preparing for the paper---thatÕs a Bibliography). Follow these guidelines:
á At SES, you donÕt need to make a separate Works Cited page; just make a section at the end of your paper.
á Center the title Works Cited at the beginning of the section. Double space before the first entry.
á Begin each entry flush with the left margin. Indent the second and following lines 5 spaces.
á List entries in alphabetical order according to the authorÕs last name. If there is no author, use the first word of the title.
á In general, include the following information: author, title, publishing information, date. You donÕt need to include page numbers for books, but you do for periodicals.
á An entry for a book would look like this:
Hemingway, Ernest. The Old Man and the Sea. New York: Scribner, 1952.
á An entry for a magazine would look like this:
Marx, Arthur. ÒEnvironmental Disaster.Ó Newsweek 21 Mar. 1996: 7-10.
Citing Electronic Sources
When citing sources from the Internet,
the general rule is to include the following information whenever available:
AuthorÕs surname, first name. ÒTitle of article or document.ÓAND?OR Title of site. Last update or copyright. Name of institution or organization associated with the site. Date you retrieved the document. <URL>
For example:
Bowker,
Samuel. ÒSaving the WoodsÓ 12 May 2003. Nature Convervancy.
15 September 2003. <WWW:http://www.nature.org./issues/stb/html.>
If the Website doesnÕt give you all of the documentation information, just include what you can. The most important items are the authorÕs name, title of document, date retrieved, and the address.
**Due to the rapidly changing nature of Internet research, itÕs best to go to http://www.mla.org/style for the most current method of citing Internet sources.
Citing Literary Works
If you are only discussing one piece of prose literature in your essay, it isnÕt necessary to use the authorÕs name in your parenthetical citation. You may just give the page number(s) in parentheses.
If you are quoting a poem, you should include the line numbers of the poem rather than a page number.
If you are quoting verse drama (like Shakespeare), you
should include the number of the act and scene as well as the line
number(s). For example: (1.2.133-135)
When to underline, when
to use quotation marks:
Underlining/Italics
Underlining is the same as italics in word processing.
Italicize or underline:
|
á titles of magazines |
á newspapers |
|
á pamphlets |
á books |
|
á plays |
á films |
|
á radio and television programs |
á book-length poems |
|
á ballets |
á operas |
|
á lengthy musical compositions |
á record albums |
|
á CDÕs |
á legal cases |
|
á scientific names of species |
á the names of ships and aircraft |
ÒQuotation MarksÓ
Use quotation marks to punctuate:
|
á Òtitles of songsÓ |
á ÒpoemsÓ |
|
á Òshort storiesÓ |
á ÒlecturesÓ |
|
á ÒcoursesÓ |
á Òradio or television programsÓ |
|
á Òchapters of booksÓ |
á Òunpublished worksÓ |
á Òarticles from magazines, newspapers,
or encyclopediasÓ
The research documentation style often used in science,
social science, and social studies courses in college is the method developed
by the American Psychological Association (APA). At SES, you may be asked to write some of your papers in APA
Style. As always, remember that other schools and publishers may
require a different citation format.
Always find out what format is required for your audience, or by your
instructor, and follow that format.
APA format is discussed
in detail with examples in WriterÕs Inc. #285-296, or Write for College # 372-443. A continually updated source for the most current
guidelines for APA Style can be found on the APA website. Go to http://www.apa.org
Two unique features of the APA Style include the use of an Abstract (a 100-150 word summary of your paper) and a References section (rather than a Works Cited or Bibliography).
A few other differences from MLA Style are:
Parenthetical Citations
Instead of just putting the authorÕs last name and page number as you do in MLA Style, in APA Style, the citation includes the date of the publication and the abbreviation for page (p. or pp.). So a typical APA Style parenthetical citation looks like:
ÒQuoteÓ (Author, Date, p. page number)
Lynette and Thomas Long, two of the foremost
recognized experts on the trend of latchkey children, define latchkey as,
ÒÉchildren who are regularly left during some period of the day to supervise
themselvesÉor for whom care arrangements are so loosely made they are virtually
ineffectiveÓ (Long, 2003, p. 17).
If you are not using a direct quote, you do not need to incorporate the page number).
References
In MLA Style, you only list the works you cited in the paper in your Works Cited. In APA Style, your References list includes all the works you referred to in the paper.
The style for the References list is significantly different from the style used for a Works Cited. Two main differences are that you only use the authorÕs initials, and the date appears immediately after the authorÕs name. The other difference deal with formatting and punctuation. Be sure to consult an APA Style Manual for help.
Organization
q The organization enhances the message
q The ideas flow smoothly
q The speech has an inviting introduction, transitional devices and a satisfying conclusion
Use of Evidence
q Relevant evidence is used extensively
q Substantive documentation is employed
Delivery (eye contact, rate,
volume, enunciation)
q The delivery is superior
q The speaker delivers the message in a dynamic fashion
Use of Language
q Words convey the intended message in a full and rich manner
q Word choice is specific
q Strong images are conveyed
q The language flows naturally
Argumentation
q Advanced application of logical and emotional appeals are used to create persuasive arguments
SES students have the unique opportunity to use the MN Zoo as a valuable resource for learning, as well as to provide services for the Zoo. Because of our partnership between SES and the Zoo, you serve as an ambassador for both SES and the MN Zoo. Please regard this as a special privilege, and an important responsibility. The following guidelines have been developed by both SES and the MN Zoo.
When
you go to the MN Zoo to work on a project during school hours, you should
follow these steps:
á Obtain permission from an SES teacher.
á Obtain a Zoo Pass from the SES Main Office.
á Sign out in the SES Main Office.
á Walk to the Zoo (you should drive only with special permission from a teacher).
á Use the main entrance to the Zoo (if you go with a class, your teacher may open the east entrance for you, but on your own you must use the main entrance).
á Sign in at the turnstile or Guest Services desk (they will ask for your Zoo Pass, and they may ask to see a student ID).
á When you return to SES, sign in at the Main Office.
If
you need help at the MN Zoo:
á Go to Guest Services in an emergency. They can access the First Aid Office or make appropriate phone calls.
á Feel free to ask the Zoo Volunteers (in blue shirts) if you have questions about the animals, or need directions or other general information about the Zoo.
á If you need to speak to a zoo staff member, go to Guest Services and ask the attendant to call the staff member. Unless you have been working with a staff member, itÕs usually best to make an appointment.
General
rules of conduct for SES students at the MN Zoo: